21 March 2023
Hello dear people,
(This is Marc writing.)
Yesterday was the long-anticipated visit to the University of Pittsburgh ALS Clinic. A crew of three accompanied Hanna to the visit. Here’s a summary of our impressions, what the doctor had to say, and what happens next.
This visit came in the midst of a particularly difficult couple of weeks. Hanna caught COVID two weeks ago, which brought her energy even lower than before and caused a loss of some of her hard-earned weight gain. The night before the ALS clinic visit, Hanna had what we eventually learned was a stomach bug: a low fever, and unable to eat without vomiting. In her words, “I’m feeling really, really, really shitty in this time. The weakest I’ve ever felt.”
So yes. Let’s get to the clinic already.
The clinic
This is a “multidisciplinary care and clinical research center” for ALS. We felt the “multidisciplinary” part throughout. Hanna has been benefitting from that even before today. The nutritionist she’s seeing, for example, is part of this clinic’s team.
We felt we were in seasoned, listening, caring professional hands. It wasn’t rushed, we had the doctor’s full attention, communication was great. They took the stance of partnership in wherever this all goes.
Diagnosis
The doctor had studied Hanna’s previous tests and records. Yesterday he spent time talking with her, asking questions, and testing strength and reflex in different parts of her body. And then he said that he believes this ALS. “90%.”
That last 10% has to do with possible autoimmune disorders. So the clinic is scheduling tests to make sure they aren’t missing something. More about that in “next steps” below.
That test will happen in the next month, and meanwhile this clinic will work with Hanna as if she has ALS. Hanna’s young age and the quick progression of symptoms is not typical. They aren’t going to waste time.
Causes
The doctor discussed the cause of ALS, and the truth is that the cause is unknown. It is not one disease, but a family of diseases. Different people experience different rates of progression and different life spans.
Thinking of some of you, we asked about the COVID vaccine. The doctor said he hears that question often, but the reality is that they are not seeing the connection in their patients. A small number of cases are something called “Familial ALS,” with a genetic connection. Hanna’s family history has nothing that suggests this may be her story, but the doctor offered testing if she wants it.
This is hard. How do we live with hard?
This is bad news. There’s no getting around it. We have to act as though this is ALS. And if it is ALS, no one can predict its progress.
The ALS clinic works with a neuropsychologist, who offers insight and counseling to Hanna and her caregivers. This is one part of a larger team (this is why they say “multidisciplinary”). There are specialists in nutrition, counseling, physical therapy, and more. Together they will work to slow the progression of symptoms and support quality of life.
The doctor surprised us with his confidence that we will see a slowing of Hanna’s progression. As we listened together, feeling pressed by the prospects ahead, we were struck by the doctor’s confident statement: “ALS is not a death sentence.”
I know we will be repeating that statement in our minds through days to come.
Another thing I’ll say about “living with hard” is that we aren’t alone in this. Hanna is not alone. The people closest to her are not alone. You are not alone. It has been about twenty-four hours since we left the clinic carrying the news of “90%.” There has not been much “alone” since. A group debrief with crackers after the visit. People coming and going from Hanna’s apartment. A rally around the to-do list. And now among other things this update to you.
I wrote this to the group this morning: “Thank you for the sense of lift we create together, stronger than the pull of gravity.”
If you feel Hanna’s story and this update as a pull of gravity, I hope you’ll talk about it with someone. There’s lift to be found in the flow of caring conversation.
Maintaining weight, getting sleep
The daily work now is maintaining weight, getting sleep, and engaging with life. Relating, creating, giving and receiving.
Weight and sleep are more important than medication. The doctor gave us some suggestions, and things like the meal train and help lists are already helping. (Thank you!)
Next steps: a rhythm of life, inquiry, monitoring and care
Here’s what’s happening now: life goes on, with a few new tweaks.
– Hanna will have a test called MRI Tractography. It’s like a regular MRI, but color codes visuals to show markers of autoimmune disorder. It won’t give positive or negative confirmation of ALS. But it may reveal something suspicious. If it does, the clinic will chase the possibility that this is autoimmune-related.
– Hanna is feeling her lungs weakening. She sometimes experiences breathing difficulty, and this is related to the quality of her sleep. She’ll soon be seeing a pulmonologist to learn more and seek support.
– Hanna will have new medication. There are three FDA-approved ALS medications, all designed to slow progression and prolong life. There’s no reason not to take all three.
– This begins a rhythm of tests every three months, monitoring weight, breathing, mood, sleep, and experience, adjusting treatment and support along the way.
– We asked about clinical trials, and the doctor said he’d like to wait a month or so until we have a 100% diagnosis of ALS. At that point, he said, “All the important trials are happening here.”
– And there will be a few other visits with specialists who can provide their particular kind of insight and support.
Thank you, as always, for your continuing care and support. It’s so… substantial.
If you’re new to this story and site and wondering what might be helpful, there’s a newish page with information about that: How can I help?
Love and buoyancy to you.
Thank you for this update. I am grateful for who you both are.
sending love and only good thoughts your way!
Grazie, Marc, for composing these careful, clear, and thorough notes to keep Hanna’s loving circle apprised. Your own love and steady support infuse your report. It’s so difficult to keep the balance of fear, hope, anger, determination, and powerful caregiving …as you manage to do. I’m thankful, as you said, that Hanna is in this city in which there is excellent diagnostic, palliative, regenerative, holistic care for ALS. PLUS groundbreaking research and creative thinkers. I’m certain that Hanna has created a foundation of strength in all was that will serve her in tackling this mondo challenge. Big big hugs for all of you. We’ll stay tuned, rooting and supporting Hanna through all the channels you’ve established. I’m especially focused on the importance of healthy food in helping her maintain weight, strength, and stamina.
Onward!
xo
Thank you Marc for letting us know. We are far away in South Africa but we are praying for Hanna.
We send lots of love.
Thank you for keeping me abreast of Hanna’s progress. I also want to thank you for freedom to tell Hanna’s story. There is a whole network of people with resources to meet Hanna’s needs. The clarity of your communications is helping me see how I can best support my dear friend.
Little Girl
Deep within
Asks
What is hard?
I replied,
Hard is where you need
A downpour of Love!
Marc, your careful, clear communication is a much appreciated gift for those of us who love Hanna and want to understand what’s happening.
Thank you.
Liewe Liewe Hannah,
You are in my thoughts and prayers more often than you would ever know.
Wish I was closer… I appreciate knowing you and walking this path in writing with you.
May you find yourself at home in your own heart. Sending you love and life.
Xxxxx Marianne
Hi Mark, thank you for helping us to be part of Hannah’s journey. This quote means a lot: “Thank you for the sense of lift we create together, stronger than the pull of gravity.” It is real lift to read about the hands-on community so close to Hannah, especially as I am physically far away. And a wonderful greeting – Love and buoyancy to you
Thank you Marc for communicating so well. It is wonderful that you share the update. We are praying. And sending big virtual hugs.
Thank you for these comments, all. Thank you for that sweet poem, Karen.
Christine, I think the image of lift created by our movement together probably came from the way David Whyte’s poem “Working together” has come to reside in my nut.
. . .
We shape our self
to fit this world
and by the world
are shaped again.
The visible
and the invisible
working together
in common cause,
to produce
the miraculous.
I am thinking of the way
the intangible air
traveled at speed
round a shaped wing
easily
holds our weight.
So may we, in this life
trust
to those elements
we have yet to see
or imagine,
and look for the true
shape of our own self,
by forming it well
to the great
intangibles about us.
Sad to hear that ALS seems likely, and inspired by all that you write about Hannah’s support network. Praying.
Thank you, Marc. Much love to Hanna and all those who are caring for and about her. <3
I met my friend Hanna in a Madwomen writing workshop at Carlow University. She is a creative and beautiful writer. Over the years our friendship has grown. She is young, smart, kind and very generous. My heart breaks knowing they are 90% sure she has ALS. I ask that you kindly contribute to help me help Hanna the best way I know. Who knows, Your dollar may be the one that changes Hanna’s life through a cure and/or better scientific knowledge. I thank you or honoring my 70th birthday.
My Facebook Birthday Fundraiser.
Thank you Karen. That’s lovely. I think this is right, yes?
Link to Karen’s birthday fundraiser for the ALS Association:
https://www.facebook.com/donate/760907272106998/10160734830382103/
I need to voice how grateful I am for these updates. I do not have it in me to be as clear and thoughtful as you right now. But I am so thankful to have these.